Mechanical vs Ultrasonic Wind Sensors: What's the Difference and Where Does Acu-Res® Fit In?

January 29, 2026

Introduction

 

Wind sensors (Anemometers) are essential across industries from marine navigation to industrial safety systems and weather monitoring. Traditionally, many systems used mechanical wind sensors, but ultrasonic technologies are increasingly relied upon. However, ultrasonic is not a single technology and there are key differences within ultrasonic wind sensing itself. This article breaks down:

  • Mechanical Wind Sensors
  • Ultrasonic Wind Sensors (Time-of-Flight)
  • Acoustic Resonance (Acu-Res®) Ultrasonic Wind Sensors
8 - wind farm
3911 - Weather station for measuring wind velocity anemometer - moviafilmes

What is a Mechanical Wind Sensor / Anemometer?

In essence, mechanical or propeller-based anemometers operate using moving parts: rotating cups or propellers to measure wind speed and a vane to determine wind direction. While mechanical wind sensors can output data at a high rate under favourable conditions, their physical response to rapidly changing wind is limited by inertia, resulting in increased latency. Although mechanical anemometers have long been a standard solution, their reliance on moving components leads to wear over time, requiring regular recalibration, maintenance, and eventual replacement.

  • Bearings and mechanical wear: Continuous exposure to wind, weather, and vibration may lead to fatigue, corrosion, or deterioration, resulting in decreased accuracy or complete failure.
  • Wiring or electrical issues: Because the rotating parts generate electrical signals, they rely on wiring and connectors. Loose or corroded connections can cause intermittent or complete loss of signal and inaccurate readings, and mechanical wind sensors are also more vulnerable to damage from lightning strikes and electrical surges along the cabling.
  • Impact damage: A collision or accidental contact can cause misalignment, bending, or component breakage, impairing its ability to rotate freely and provide accurate wind measurement.
  • Accumulation of debris: The cups or propellers in mechanical anemometers accumulate dirt, dust, salt, or other debris, affecting the wind sensor’s rotation, leading to reduced sensitivity, inaccurate readings, or complete blockage of the moving parts.
  • Ice formation: In colder climates or during winter sailing, the ice accumulation on the anemometer’s rotating components can cause obstruction or imbalance, resulting in inaccurate or non-responsive wind measurements. Ice formation also increases the weight on the sensor, leading to strain and damage.
  • Corrosion: Exposure to saltwater, humidity, and harsh marine environments can cause corrosion on the wind sensor’s metal components including bearings, shafts, or connectors. Corrosion can impair the sensor’s movement, affecting its ability to rotate smoothly and generate reliable wind data.

Mechanical wind sensors may still be suitable for basic or low-maintenance environments, but for demanding applications they often fall short.

What is an Ultrasonic Wind Sensor?

Ultrasonic wind sensors are solid-state devices; they have no mechanical moving parts and instead use sound waves to determine wind speed and direction.

However, not all ultrasonic technologies are the same.

 

Time-of-Flight (ToF) ultrasonic wind sensors



Traditional ultrasonic wind sensors send acoustic pulses between spatially separated transducers. The time it takes for sound to travel between these points changes when wind is present, and this difference is used to calculate wind speed and direction.

  • Requires several centimetres of open measurement path between exposed transducers
  • Can be sensitive to temperature, pressure, rain and humidity effects
  • Performance may be affected by environmental interference along the acoustic path
  • Exposed transducer geometry can be susceptible to physical obstruction or damage, including bird interaction in some installations
  • Works well in general meteorological and other low-risk environments

Acoustic Resonance (Acu-Res®) ultrasonic wind sensors



FT Technologies uses a proprietary Acoustic Resonance (Acu-Res®) measurement method instead of Time-of-Flight (ToF). In this approach:

  • Sound waves resonate within a small cavity
  • Changes in the phase of the resonating wave caused by wind are used to measure wind speed and direction, creating a very strong low-noise signal that is easier to measure in challenging conditions.
  • This compact cavity and resonant design make the sensor more resilient to interference and environmental noise than typical ToF ultrasonic sensors.
  • Bonus: FT's latest Acu-Res® wind sensor models measure wind speed, direction, temperature, wind pressure, pitch, roll, and compass heading — all from a single compact unit. Ideal for dynamic marine and industrial platforms.

Put simply, both Time-of-Flight (ToF) and Acoustic Resonance (Acu-Res® ) are ultrasonic technologies, but Acu-Res® offers distinct performance advantages.

ToF vs FT Acu-Res

Mechanical vs Ultrasonic: Key Differences

 

Feature Mechanical Ultrasonic Time-of-Flight (ToF) Ultrasonic Acoustic Resonance (Acu-Res®)
Moving parts Yes No No
Maintenance High Low None
Measurement method Cups and Vane Pulse transit time (ToF) Resonant wave phase (Acu-Res®)
Environmental sensitivity High Moderate Very low
Response speed Fast to low Fast Very fast
Size Larger Medium to Compact Compact
Robustness in harsh conditions Moderate to Low Moderate Very high
Typical use Basic installations General meteorology Industrial, marine, other critical applications

 

Conclusion:

Mechanical Wind Sensors: Most are well-suited to simple, low-cost, low-precision applications where periodic recalibration and component replacement are acceptable. Situations where maintenance is manageable and environmental conditions are benign.

Ultrasonic (ToF) Wind Sensors: Good for general meteorology and basic solid-state requirements as it offers improved performance over mechanical with minimal maintenance or replacement but may still be affected by environmental exposure in harsher installations.

Acoustic Resonance (Acu-Res®) Wind Sensors: Excellent for offshore and marine environments, industrial safety and control systems; dynamic and mobile platforms (e.g. crewed and unmanned vessels, offshore structures, drones and aerial systems).

Acoustic Resonance wind sensors provide high accuracy, rapid response, and exceptional durability in challenging conditions. With no recalibration or routine maintenance required, their compact, protected sensing design reduces exposure to environmental damage, resulting in greater long-term reliability and fewer sensor replacements. As a result, Acu-Res® wind sensors can deliver lower total cost of ownership over the lifetime of an installation, despite a higher initial investment.

Designed for some of the harshest operating environments, FT Acu-Res® wind sensors minimise failure modes associated with exposure and wear, helping extend service life and reduce replacement cycles.

FT742-DM in Icing Conditions

Best-in-Class Durability

Acoustic Resonance wind sensors provide high accuracy, rapid response, and exceptional durability in challenging conditions, delivering lower lifetime cost of ownership than both mechanical and conventional ultrasonic designs.

FAQs: Mechanical vs Ultrasonic Wind Sensors

 

Q1:  What is the difference between mechanical and ultrasonic wind sensors? 

Mechanical wind sensors use moving parts to measure wind, while ultrasonic wind sensors use sound waves and have no moving components.
Mechanical anemometers rely on cups, propellers, and vanes physically rotating in the wind, which introduces inertia, wear, and maintenance requirements. Ultrasonic wind sensors calculate wind speed and direction electronically using ultrasonic signals, delivering faster response, higher reliability, and lower long-term maintenance, particularly in harsh or safety-critical environments.

Q2: Are ultrasonic wind sensors more accurate than mechanical wind sensors?

Ultrasonic wind sensors are typically more consistent over time, but the most accurate choice depends on the specific sensor model and quality. 
Mechanical sensors can be accurate when new, but bearing wear, friction, and inertia can reduce their ability to capture sharp gusts and rapid turbulence. Some high-end mechanical sensors can be just as accurate, and in some cases even better. FT’s Acu-Res® ultrasonic wind sensors maintain accuracy throughout their service life, offering fast response and stable performance without degradation from moving parts. While many ultrasonic sensors avoid mechanical wear, some Time-of-Flight designs may still lose data in heavy rain or require additional protection from lightning and contamination.

Q3: Do all ultrasonic wind sensors work the same way?

No. Ultrasonic wind sensors use different measurement principles.
There are two primary ultrasonic approaches:
•    Time-of-Flight (ToF): Measures changes in the travel time of sound pulses between exposed transducers.
•    Acoustic Resonance (Acu-Res®): Measures phase changes in a resonating ultrasonic wave within a protected cavity.
Both ToF and Acu-Res® ultrasonic methods are ultrasonic wind technologies, but they differ significantly in robustness, environmental tolerance, and performance in challenging conditions.

Q4: Is Acoustic Resonance still considered ultrasonic technology?

Yes. Acoustic Resonance is a form of ultrasonic wind sensing.
Acu-Res® uses ultrasonic sound waves, placing it firmly within the ultrasonic category. However, unlike Time-of-Flight systems, it measures changes in the phase of a resonating wave rather than pulse transit time. This makes Acoustic Resonance a more advanced and resilient subset of ultrasonic wind sensor technology, particularly suited to harsh marine, industrial, and offshore environments.

Q5: Which wind sensor is best for harsh or offshore environments?

Ultrasonic wind sensors are generally best suited for harsh and offshore environments due to their solid-state design and greater tolerance to environmental stress.

FT wind sensors use proprietary Acu-Res® acoustic resonance technology, which enables a compact, protected sensing cavity that performs reliably in motion and rain. The high signal-to-noise ratio supports high accuracy and fast output rates up to 10 Hz, even in changing conditions.

FT wind sensors are also designed for long-term exposure to salt spray and corrosive marine atmospheres, validated to ISO 9227:2006. In addition, they have passed surge and electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) tests, including EN 61000-4-5:2006, to support reliable operation in electrically harsh offshore environments.

Acu-Res® Technology

FT Technologies' Acu-Res® gives a signal to noise ratio more than 40dB stronger than other ultrasonic technologies. This wind measurement method is unique to FT Technologies, making the sensors more robust and reliable compared to alternatives on the market. Watch the video to take a closer look at how it works.